When Should Your Child Start Nursery? Everything About the Ideal Starting Age

‍

The question "When should my child start nursery?" is far more than a logistical entry in young parents' calendars. It's one of the most emotionally charged and complex decisions mothers and fathers must make during their child's early years. It touches upon parents' own sense of identity, frequently sits at the intersection of competing life choices, and is often debated publicly in controversial and ideologically charged terms. Whilst early non-parental childcare is accepted societal norm in Scandinavia or France, the German-speaking world—and to some extent Switzerland—still harbours a lingering scepticism towards early external care.

Yet emotions and traditions make poor advisors when it comes to a child's neurological and psychological development. This report aims to bring objectivity to the debate. We're leaving behind the realm of opinions and entering the territory of evidence-based science. Drawing on current findings from developmental psychology, neuroscience, and attachment research, we analyse which factors truly determine whether and when external childcare benefits a child.

One thing quickly becomes clear: the question isn't solely "When?" but, more importantly, "Where?" The quality of the setting is the decisive variable that determines whether a nursery represents stress or stimulation, risk or resilience factor. This guide serves as a navigation tool for parents who want to understand what happens in their child's brain when they're integrated into a group setting, how to recognise genuine pedagogical quality, and how to determine the optimal starting point for their individual child.

The Neurobiological Foundations of the Early Years

To understand when a child is ready for nursery, we must first understand what's happening in their head during the early years. The period from birth to the third year of life is often referred to as "the first 1000 days" and represents the most critical window of neurological development.

Synaptogenesis and the Learning Brain

At birth, the human brain possesses billions of neurones, yet these are barely interconnected. During the first three years of life, the number of synapses—the connections between nerve cells—explodes. This process, synaptogenesis, is largely driven by experience. "Use it or lose it" is the guiding principle: connections that are utilised strengthen; those unused atrophy (pruning).

During this phase, the brain is extraordinarily plastic and receptive, but also vulnerable. It requires two things in balance:

1. Security (attachment): To regulate the stress system and provide energy for growth.
2. Stimulation (education): To build sensory, motor, and cognitive networks.

Settings that work according to modern curricula, such as the Early Years Curriculum (EYC®) at Little Star Day School, are founded precisely on this understanding. They see themselves not merely as childcare, but as learning and developmental environments where children receive targeted, age-appropriate support—whether through bilingual input, purposeful sensory activities, or social interaction spaces.

Attachment Theory in the 21st Century

For a long time, attachment theory according to John Bowlby was interpreted to mean that separation from the mother during the early years was inherently harmful. Modern research paints a more nuanced picture. Attachment is not an exclusive bond to a single person, but rather a hierarchical system.

The NICHD study (National Institute of Child Health and Human Development), one of the world's largest longitudinal studies on childcare, has demonstrated that it's not the fact of external care that determines attachment security, but rather the sensitivity of caregivers—both parents at home and educators at nursery.

‍

Table: Factors Influencing Attachment Security According to NICHD

‍

The conclusion: A child comes to no harm when they allow an additional attachment figure (their key person) into their life. On the contrary: a rich network of trusting relationships strengthens resilience. The prerequisite, however, is that the nursery enables these relationships—through consistent key persons rather than constantly changing staff.

Age Stages in Detail — When Is the Right Time for Nursery?

The question "When should my child start nursery?" cannot be answered universally, as the developmental needs of a 6-month-old infant are fundamentally different from those of a 2-year-old. We analyse the advantages and disadvantages for the various age stages.

Starting Nursery Under 1 Year (Infants)

Starting nursery during the first year of life feels particularly sensitive for many parents. The bond is still very close, daily routines are highly synchronised, and the thought of an early separation often triggers mixed feelings and questions.

Challenges:

• Physiological regulation: Infants cannot yet regulate their own emotions and physiological states (hunger, sleep, stress). They are 100% dependent on co-regulation by adults.
• Immune system: The immune system is still developing; infections are more frequent.

Opportunities and Prerequisites:

When quality is right, early care can offer advantages. Settings like Little Star employ specialised concepts such as the "Nappy Curriculum" and "Bottle Bridge".

What is the Nappy Curriculum?

The Nappy Curriculum© is an educational concept for babies in their first year of life. It deliberately places care situations—such as nappy changing, feeding, and soothing—at the heart of daily life. Rather than treating these as mere routine, these moments are purposefully used to build relationships and promote development: in 1:1 situations, babies experience intensive eye contact, sensitive communication ("I'm lifting your legs now"), and reliable, individualised attention. At the same time, the Nappy Curriculum© ensures that nutrition and daily routines remain as individualised as possible until the first birthday.

Bottle Bridge

Programmes such as "Bottle Bridge" support breastfeeding parents in maintaining breastfeeding or making a well-supported transition to bottle feeding. The aim is for the baby to feel securely and reliably nourished at nursery—regardless of whether they're breastfed, bottle-fed, or gradually introduced to complementary foods.

Conclusion for Under 1s:

A nursery start in the first year of life is possible when the staff-to-child ratio is very high (ideally 1:2 or 1:3) and the setting has specialised baby rooms that are spatially separated from the noisier toddler groups—and when there's a clear concept for attachment, care, and nutrition such as the Nappy Curriculum©.

Starting Nursery at 1 to 2 Years (Toddlers)

Between the first and second birthday, the autonomy phase begins. Children become mobile and start actively exploring the world.

Developmental Psychology Considerations:

• Exploration: The child physically separates from their parents. A secure nursery environment often offers more stimuli (materials, movement spaces) than the home living room.
• Social interest: Whilst children at this age often still play alongside one another (parallel play), they observe other children intently and learn through imitation.
• Language: The sensitive period for language begins. A bilingual environment (such as German/English at Little Star) can be particularly effective now, as the brain still absorbs sounds intuitively.

Critical Points:

• Separation anxiety: Around 12 to 18 months, separation anxiety often reaches a fresh peak (rapprochement crisis). A settling-in process during precisely this window requires particular patience and sensitivity following the Berlin Model.

Starting Nursery from 3 Years Onwards

From three years of age, the child transforms from "nestling" to "world explorer".

Scientific Consensus:

From this age, almost all experts recommend attending a setting.

• Social competence: Children now need the "peer group" to practise conflict resolution, sharing, empathy, and assertiveness. A child who only interacts with adults until school entry often has deficits in social behaviour with peers.
• Cognitive demands: The brain requires more complex nourishment. Structured curricula, projects, and initial mathematical or scientific concepts prepare children for school.

‍

Table: Developmental Needs and Nursery Requirements by Age

The Myth of Stress – Cortisol, Quality and Resilience

A common argument against early nursery attendance is studies demonstrating elevated cortisol levels (stress hormone) in nursery children. Critics such as Dr Rainer Böhm or interpretations of the Vienna nursery study are frequently cited. Yet a careful analysis of the data shows: stress is not simply stress.

The Vermeer Meta-Analysis and Its Significance

The meta-analysis by Vermeer and van IJzendoorn confirmed that whilst cortisol levels in nurseries often don't decline as sharply in the afternoon as they do at home (or even rise slightly), it also identified the crucial moderators:

1. Quality of the setting: In settings with low quality, the stress increase was significantly higher. In settings with high pedagogical quality, it was often barely measurable or non-existent.
2. Social interaction: Part of the cortisol increase is attributable to social stimulation ("positive stress" or eustress) that arises during play and interaction and is not inherently harmful.
3. Settling-in: Children who were gently settled and have a secure attachment to their key person show normal cortisol patterns.

Toxic Stress vs. Positive Stress

The child's brain distinguishes between:

• Toxic stress: Prolonged anxiety, overwhelm, loneliness without a comforting caregiver. This damages the hippocampus and development.
• Positive stress: Challenges (new toy, conflict over a spade) that are navigated with support. This promotes resilience.

The Role of Staff Ratios:

To prevent toxic stress, a practitioner must be immediately available when a child cries. With a ratio of 1:12 (as is sometimes the case in Germany or in state-run settings), this is realistically barely achievable. A favourable staff ratio—for instance, one practitioner for three babies rather than six or eight—enables swift co-regulation: the child repeatedly experiences "When I'm stressed, someone is there." This experience stabilises the stress system and prevents persistently elevated cortisol levels.

Noise and Sensory Overload

An often underestimated stressor is noise. Noise levels exceeding 80 dB (comparable to a busy main road) are not uncommon in less favourable nurseries.

Solution Through Design and Approach: Good nurseries work with sound insulation, clearly structured spaces, and fixed quiet periods to reduce the acoustic environment. At Little Star, this is evident in separate areas for different age groups—such as baby sleep rooms and quiet corners or discovery zones—as well as in regular use of outdoor spaces like the garden, forest, or city walks. This relieves group dynamics and can significantly reduce the perceived noise for children.

The Window of Opportunities — Bilingual Education and Cognitive Advantages

A significant argument for nursery attendance—and indeed an early start—is utilising sensitive periods for learning that often cannot be replicated at home. Bilingualism is particularly noteworthy here.

Neuroplasticity and Language Acquisition

During the first three to five years of life, the brain is a "language genius". It doesn't store languages through laborious vocabulary learning (declarative memory), but absorbs them implicitly (procedural memory).

Broca's Area: Studies show that with early bilingualism, both languages are processed in the same region of Broca's area. With late learning (e.g. at school), the languages use separate areas, which is cognitively more demanding.

Critical Period: The ability to distinguish and reproduce phonemes without an accent begins to decline gradually from 12 months of age and closes almost completely by the end of puberty.

The Immersion Principle at Little Star

The most effective method is immersion (a "language bath"). Little Star applies the "One Person – One Language" principle.

• One practitioner speaks consistently in German (Swiss German/Standard German).
• One practitioner speaks consistently in English.

The child doesn't need to "learn"; they live in both languages. They sing, eat, play, and find comfort in both languages.

Advantages of This Approach:

1. Cognitive flexibility: Bilingual children constantly train their executive functions (attention control). They must actively suppress the language not in use (inhibition), which trains the brain like a muscle. They can often switch between tasks more effectively (task switching).
2. Metalinguistic awareness: They understand earlier that words are merely symbols for things. This promotes abstract thinking.
3. Cultural openness: Language conveys culture. In Little Star's international groups (the Zug and Zurich locations attract many expats), diversity becomes the norm.

When to Start with Bilingualism?

The research is unequivocal: the earlier, the better. Starting at 6 months or 1 year harnesses the full potential of neuroplasticity. Starting at 3 or 4 years is still very good, but often requires somewhat more conscious effort from the child than the intuitive absorption during infancy. So if effortless bilingualism is valued, this provides a strong argument for an early nursery start in a bilingual setting.

Quality Criteria — How Parents Recognize a Good Nursery

How can parents tell whether a nursery meets high quality standards? The following criteria help with assessment.

Educational Approach: Clear Framework Rather Than Random Principle

A nursery shouldn't simply "get on with it", but should work according to a clear pedagogical approach.

Important points:

• Well-considered curriculum: A structured early years concept ensures that all developmental areas—motor skills, sensory development, language, social competence, early mathematical abilities, and creativity—are systematically addressed and that activities are age-appropriate.
• Individualisation: Every child has their own pace. Good settings document developmental steps (e.g. through portfolios or regular development meetings) and adapt activities accordingly.

A useful question from parents is: "How do you document my child's development?"

Structural Quality

• Location and environment: High-quality nurseries actively use their surroundings—whether an urban setting with trips to the library, market, or museum, or a location close to nature with regular visits to the lake, forest, or park. Children aren't isolated but experience the "real world" within a protected framework.
• Spaces and equipment: Bright, well-structured rooms, retreat spaces, separate sleep rooms for babies, clear functional areas (e.g. movement room, discovery corner, creative area), and secure outdoor spaces are an important part of pedagogical quality.

Nutrition

• Fresh, balanced meals: Age-appropriate, balanced nutrition with fresh ingredients supports physical and cognitive development. Nutrients such as omega-3 fatty acids, iron, and vitamins are important for the child's brain.
• In-house or closely supervised kitchen team: Whether an in-house kitchen or external caterer—what matters is that the setting has clear standards for quality, freshness, and child-appropriate food and communicates these transparently.

Parents can ask specifically: "How are meals planned and prepared?"

Partnership with Parents

A good nursery sees itself as a partner to families.

• Transparency: Regular feedback about the day (e.g. through informal chats, an app, or daily reports) gives parents insight into what the child has eaten, played, and learnt—and how they were feeling.
• Reliable organisation: Opening hours that are compatible with family life, as few closure days as possible, and clear cover arrangements reduce organisational pressure. Less stressed parents can be emotionally more present and sensitive with their child—which indirectly benefits nursery life as well.

The Settling-In Process – The Critical Success Factor

Regardless of whether the child is 6 months or 3 years old: the transition from family to nursery is a psychological feat for all involved. If settling-in fails, attachment trauma and negative stress are risks.

The Berlin Model in Detail

The gold standard, which Little Star also employs, is the Berlin Settling-in Model. It is attachment-focused and child-centred.

Phase 1: The Foundation Phase (Days 1-3)

One parent (ideally the primary caregiver) comes with the child to nursery for approximately 1-2 hours.

• Rule: Parents are passive but present ("secure base"). They don't read the newspaper but are emotionally available.
• Goal: The child becomes familiar with the rooms and key person under the protection of their mother/father. No separation!

Phase 2: First Separation Attempt (Day 4)

The parent says goodbye briefly (!) and leaves the room for a maximum of 30 minutes, but remains in the building.

• Response A: Child cries briefly but allows themselves to be comforted by the key person and continues playing. → Success. Settling-in can proceed swiftly (approximately 2 weeks total).
• Response B: Child cries inconsolably, freezes, or cannot be calmed. → Abort. Parent returns immediately. Return to foundation phase. Settling-in is extended (3-4 weeks or longer).

Phase 3: Stabilisation Phase

Separation times are gradually increased. Only when the child accepts the key person as a "secure base" (i.e. allows themselves to be comforted by them) is settling-in complete.

Psychology of Parents: Learning to Let Go

Often it's the parents who suffer more than the children. Children have fine antennae. If the mother is uncertain at goodbye, anxious, or feeling guilty ("bad mother"), the child senses: "It's not safe here, otherwise Mummy wouldn't look at me so worried."

Tip: Address your ambivalences before nursery starts. Trust the setting. A brief, cheerful goodbye ritual signals security.

Conclusion: Determining the Right Starting Point

The question "When should my child start nursery?" cannot be answered in a single sentence, but based on the research, we can outline broad parameters:

• From 3 years: Nursery attendance makes considerable sense from a developmental psychology perspective—particularly for social and cognitive development.
• From 1–2 years: Nursery experiences can significantly support language (including bilingualism), autonomy, and social learning when the conditions are right.
• From 6–12 months: An early start can succeed and, according to current research, is not harmful, provided the quality is very high—with favourable staff ratios, specialised infant care (e.g. Nappy Curriculum), and consistent key persons.

Settings such as Little Star Day School demonstrate how modern nursery care that complements family life can be designed: not as a replacement for the family, but as an enhancement. Children gain an additional space for experience where they can explore, hear languages, and form friendships—embedded within a network of professional pedagogy and parental closeness.

Ultimately, it remains a personal decision. With knowledge of neuroplasticity, attachment security, and clear quality criteria, however, this decision can be guided less by fear and more by informed conviction.